Does this logic make sense (long. don't answer if you aren't willing to read it)?

I don't see why you are limiting the spatial dimensions to three and then considering only temporal dimensions after that. It is entirely possible to have a universe with more than three spatial dimensions as well as a further dimension of time, in fact I could write you a computer program to simulate a (small) universe of this kind and some people have probably already done so. In fact, there is no reason to set a cap on how many spatial dimensions you can have, mathematically it is possible to keep on adding spatial dimensions indefinitely. Similarly, it is entirely possible to have universes with only one or two spatial dimensions along with a dimension of time, and I know for a fact that people have written computer programs to simulate universes of this kind (and furthermore it has been demonstrated that some one-dimensional universes are capable of simulating higher-dimensional universes, just as we can simulate four-dimensional space in our own computers occupying three-dimensional space). All in all I think your ideas are based on unrealistically restrictive premises, and I'm also not too keen on trying to tie it in with religion at the end.